Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lord Scrotum's avatar

Interesting and valid points. Both yourself and Peter Hitchens have pointed out that the whole "fwee twade", deregulated markets schtick really isn't conservatism, at least in any classic Burkean mould. It's neoliberalism. Libertarianism. Thatcher took this from Sir Keith Joseph who in turn took this from Milton Friedman ("The Road to Serfdom" IIRC). And it was very much the moral case that won them over: 1970s Labour govts had implemented marginal tax rates in excess of 90% since Denis Healey had to go cap in hand to the IMF. There is a moral case to be made that that's not taxation, it's extortion. The Labour govt had effectively become a protection racket. There were knock-on effects too. The 1986 "big bang" saw former east-end barrow-boys becoming shit-hot traders on the foreign exchanges. Turns out that the hustle in Billingsgate is better training for that line than any laughably conformist concensus sterile MBA from LSE. The tories had broken the old-boy old-school-tie-network dominance in highly-remunerated city careers, and that too was a massive moral victory. Railing against classism and inequality was supposed to be Labour's raison d'être. The tories had succesfully pulled the rug out from under Labour's feet. Why the hell aren't the tories proudly crowing about such monumental achievements to this day?

Because it all fell apart around 1991 when Major's leadership lost that moral edge. Those around at the time will remember the persistent sleaze headlines: Harvey Proctor. Steven Milligan. David Mellor. Jeffrey Archer. Johnathan Aitken. The party had lost its intellectual edge too: Major's attempt to correct this was the feeble and rightly-lampooned "Back to Basics" campaign. Coupled with the ever-deepening split over Europe, it's where the rot set in for the tories and they've been dysfunctional ever since.

It's always been like this. If conservatives had had the moral strength to oppose sending infants up chimneys, there mightn't even be a labour party today. And maybe Karl Marx wouldn't be buried in Highgate cemetery.

The tories have a golden opportunity to reinvent themselves. Sure, they need to prostrate themselves and grovel relentlessly for their recent imbecilic form, particularly regarding immigration levels. They also need a putsch of the wets much like Thatcher had to do. History does seems to be repeating itself somewhat.

Expand full comment
Marc Czerwinski's avatar

I watched Badenoch a few days ago being interviewed by Charles Moore for the Policy Exchange.

From how she spoke, there's the potential for a serious change in direction, fleshed out policy proposals to run a radical returning small state government.

My big, and remaining criticism is that if the civil service was able to stymie things for the whole 14 years of Cameron to Sunak, what's to stop them again derailing a potentially radical Tory govt?

She is either never asked this, or wouldn't have an answer.

Of course this applies to a Reform govt, a 100x worse.

Expand full comment
48 more comments...

No posts