I have to admit, after several years of blogging Brexit, the very last thing I wanted to pivot to was the mechanics of Burnham’s SPS deal with the EU. It’s especially exhausting because it resurrects so many issue-illiterate debates where neither side has a genuine grasp of what they’re talking about.
It also has a crushing inevitability to it. I predicted that Labour would attempt something along these lines primarily because the Tories did nothing with Brexit, paving the way for Labour to easily put things back the way they were.
But Burnham is demonstrating why Brexit was necessary in the first place. Again, we have a feral government acting in open defiance, showing abject contempt for democracy, signing us up to treaties without proper consultation or a national debate, signing away powers that are not theirs to sign away.
Brexit, primarily, was about who really governs us. Again, our politicians are handing over decision-making powers to a foreign entity, supervised by a foreign court, making us a regulatory subordinate in a vital, strategic policy area – with the most spurious economic justification and a threadbare mandate.
While I am hard-pressed to go to the barricades over meat hygiene regulations when there are so many more pressing issues right now, it’s the principle of the thing. It starts with an SPS deal but it doesn’t end there. Burnham has admitted as much. Here begins an incremental process of handing powers back to Brussels, abnegating domestic governance.
Worse still, it is less to do with our economic interests and more to do with party-political tribalism and the narcissism of our elites, who put the interests of the British people last in any consideration. It’s more of the same liberal internationalism that has brought the European economy to its knees and shredded the social contract.
Moreover, an SPS deal is decidedly not in our interests. While it reduces some friction at the border, it maintains a whole raft of destructive behind-the-border regulations that have piled on costs for farmers and the meat industry, thereby favouring large factory farms and industrial slaughterhouses (the only ones who can afford the compliance). A model that is contingent on cheap foreign labour.
That’s always been the essential problem with the single market. As with haulage and many other sectors, the savings it produces for consumers come through cutting wages. When those marginal savings don’t magically reappear, it’s a safe bet that Labour will look to restore freedom of movement.
By that time, Britain will be a partial Single Market member, obeying all of the rules but without the powers of veto even enjoyed by Norway. That is the democratic deficit they will use as an excuse to rejoin the EU.
We should also recall that an SPS deal also requires the strengthening of all the flanking climate policies that have piled on even more costs, not least to fertiliser production and energy. As such, Britain will be locked into the regulatory universe that has deindustrialised Britain and handed the economic advantage to China. Labour is attempting to resurrect globalisation and neoliberalism – the religion of their creed.
On that basis, an SPS deal is not trivial. It’s what it represents that should concern us. Again, our right to decide our own fate is being pissed away by politicians who think they know better.
In resurrecting Brexit, though, Burnham is unwittingly reopening a can of worms he will come to regret. The last six years have been a Brexit truce of a sort. Neither side is especially content with the Brexit settlement as is, and it is very much unfinished business. There is still a lot of unresolved politics around the theme of Brexit, which was parked for political expedience and because everyone was sick of it.
That is certainly true for my part. Having spent the better part of a decade of my life talking about the technicalities of Brexit, I had hoped to think about different and more productive things. Bringing that all back to the fore, though, forces us to re-litigate the entire thing.
The withdrawal agreement and the TCA were inelegant compromises that were always going to be life-limited. We have entire industries drowning under the weight of EU political agendas and red tape, to the extent that the European car industry is on the brink of collapse, and the farming sector is not far behind it.
Brexit was an opportunity to rethink how we do things in virtually every sector, and a competent government armed with a Brexit plan could by now have made major reforms. There’s a whole raft of legacy EU Net Zero measures that could and should have gone on the bonfire.
Unfortunately for us, the entire enterprise was headed by the Johnson oaf with the ineffably useless Cummings in the shadows, so nothing was done. The kind of reforms needed are deeply technical in nature, requiring research-based policy and systems thinking which was and is wholly absent on the British right. This is why I’ve lambasted Reform for so long, because a second crack of the whip, with a similar lack of intellectual direction, will produce the same results.
All the same, the matter remains unresolved, and if Burnham is determined to force the issue, then all other politics are parked for now. There is no question in politics more urgent than who really governs us. Perhaps it is time the question was brought out of stasis for a final fight to the death.
As such, that brings into question the withdrawal agreement that means we’re still paying benefits to settled EU citizens. It brings into question the Northern Ireland Protocol where the tail wags the dog. It brings into question the level-playing-field non-regression clauses of the TCA. It once again brings into question the entire regulatory model upon which our economy is based. Questions we’ve avoided and kicked into the long grass.
Personally, I was content to let sleeping dogs lie for the time being, since there are other urgent matters demanding our attention, but if Burnham wants this fight then we shall have it out now, and this time there can be no compromises. No part of the United Kingdom can be supervised by foreign judges in any context – and if that means a trade war, dismantling the withdrawal agreement, and bouncing Ireland out of the single market then so be it. If we have to starve Ireland of electricity then so be it. Further still, we must forge relations with Eurosceptics on the continent and make it a foreign policy priority to destroy the EU once and for all. Further still, we must eject all EU citizens.
While that seems excessive, this is something that now demands a definitive conclusion. It is clear that our rulers will never respect the verdict of the British people and will continue to hand powers away without a mandate, and will continue to govern only in the interests of their supporters. This regime is now an intolerable threat to democracy. Some things are worth going to war over and this is one of them.



By the way the last Tory government under Theresa May removed the requirement to have a referendum to rejoin the EU.
So Andy could wave his hand and take us back in with the help of a Parliament that is as corrupt as any since Walpole.
Excellent on all points Peter. This is an existential issue. If 17 million votes can be arbitrarily ignored, we have no democracy left at all. Plus all the factors that made us want to Leave have grown in the last 10 years-the EU’s sclerotic chaos, the arrogance and lack of accountability from it and it’s UK supporters, the clear reality that we can do better outside it, all these have grown more evident, not less. The economic damage argument is a farce based entirely on counting damage from all non Brexit policies as Brexit damage. But more than that if they can get away with this level of contempt for the public they can do anything.