Probably the most totemic example of single market dynamics is the haulage industry, where Eastern European drivers working for lower pay, with inferior skills and qualifications would come to Britain for weeks at a time to undercut the domestic market, driving down wages and deterring anyone from becoming a lorry driver because the pay was unsustainable.
I was shocked when I looked into this. There were rates as low as £12 an hour for what I consider to be a highly skilled and important profession. There are several examples of this, not least care work, where the abundance of cheaper foreign labour ended up creating the domestic labour shortage, resulting in a broader deskilling of the occupation.
As such, any example you pick where politicians say the single market reduces the cost of living is contingent on low wage exploitation and wage suppression that disadvantages domestic workers.
This was also true of agriculture, where local workers were displaced in favour of essentially slave gang labour, when these are jobs that should have gone to our own young people. There was a time when veg packing plants in East Anglia would be reliable summer jobs for students and young people, but they were gradually displaced by foreigners with lower living costs and overheads. Many would share accommodation, either in temporary lodgings or illegally overcrowded HMOs.
Part of the reason they got away with it is because local councils stopped doing routine housing inspections and prosecutions for HMO overcrowding collapsed. Fines, if issued at all, are nominal. Local government indifference was part of the business model.
Essentially, any sector that relied on unskilled or semi-skilled labour turned to immigration, often preferring it to domestic labour to the extent of freezing it out entirely. They would contract out recruitment to agencies that specialised in recruiting workers from abroad. They then told us that British workers just wouldn’t do that kind of work.
Of course, that was true when wages were barely enough to cover expenses and when we told young people to go to university and live off student loans and work in call centres. Anyone not suited to university was simply thrown to the wolves or warehoused on the dole.
British workers understood this dynamic far better than any LSE economist - which is why they voted for Brexit. They expected that Brexit would curtail the use of cheaper foreign labour.
What should have happened is restrictions on the use of imported labour except for where there were structural shortages such as seasonal workers, who should only have been given temporary visas. We should then have made it harder for young people to claim benefits and deregulated the temporary labour market (not least reversing the Agency Workers Directive). What we got instead was the Boriswave with indefinite leave to remain.
As much as this was a betrayal by the Tories, squandering the opportunity of Brexit, Labour did likewise. Labour had a golden opportunity to reclaim its status as the party of British workers, by making these reforms, putting British workers first just for a change. But instead they’ve doubled down on ILR, and Burnham is seeking to restore freedom of movement, starting with the Youth Mobility Scheme. Labour is the party of the neoliberal status quo. It has no loyalty at all to the British worker.
This is all predicated on the cynical assertion that Brexit has failed - but it has only failed in the sense that both Labour and the Tories have point-blank refused to wean Britain off cheap foreign labour, or make any reforms aimed at fixing the fundamentals, and are now using that betrayal failure as a pretext to reverse Brexit.
To make good on Brexit would require some kind of political vision, based on a grounded idea of what’s gone wrong for British workers, but you can’t expect that of career bureaucrats like Keir Starmer or Burnham, or his cabinet who’ve had minimal private sector exposure - and even fewer who’ve ever had a real job. They will not act in the interests of British workers because they simply have no working concept of what those interests are.
While all of us can agree that actions must be taken to bring down the cost of living, the answer cannot be to maintain the model of low wage replacement labour. Primarily it demands we get energy costs down, but that means dumping net zero and the ideological devotion to renewable energy. But they won’t do that. Their arrogance, narcissism and stupidity forbids it. Expensive energy is an ideological choice. Since they have no other levers at their disposal, they will continue to feed the economy with the cheap foreign labour it demands, regardless of the costs and social externalities. Who cares if we’re throwing a generation of our own young people on the scrapheap?
This, of course, suits the middle class liberal (who is well insulated from the cost of living crisis) down to the ground. So long as their hotels are cheap and there’s low wage servants to do their bidding, and bring takeaways to their door, why on earth should they care?
Essentially, our political class learned nothing in 2016. If ever they did pause and reflect, all those lessons have been ejected and they’ve resumed their old habits. They think they can simply hand over powers to Brussels without consultation or consent, just as they did before. They have no ideas of their own so the repatriation of powers meant nothing to them. They want the trappings of office, but none of the responsibilities.
That is the only sense in which “Brexit has failed”. We may have left the European Union, but our membership was only ever a symptom of the political disconnect in the British establishment. Brexit was never an economic position and it was a mistake for Vote Leave to present it as such. It was always a question of who governs us and in whose interests. An equation in which the British worker is always last in the queue.
While Burnham’s smarmy veneer may charm some, his sticking plaster gimmicks are scraps from the table - and British workers still come last. His determination to undo Brexit tells us who he really serves.


