I do hope they do well and praise from Pete North is worth having. It is a lonely job being a serious political party that never gets anywhere. Maybe it has role in just being there, setting the bar and keeping a flame alive. Like opera or ballet, it doesn’t have mass appeal but we should appreciate the skill that other singers and dancers should emulate. Which won’t happen. Maybe though someone will dare to do something different. An MP jumps ship, a celebrity (bigger than Rod Liddle) signs up or a rich donor takes a punt and suddenly, the game changes.
I love reading your work Pete but you’re an idealist, a deep thinker sure but an idealist. Ideas are great and you’re right that we need right wing think tanks to inform serious right wing parties with a chance of power and putting those ideas into practice. You may mock Reform as a slop party and maybe they will fail if they should form a government which I think is highly unlikely but it wouldn’t be as disastrous as this Labour shitshow.
PS. What about an article on Burnham’s crusade to introduce PR and ensure we have a left wing coalition forever because be in no doubt if the right don’t win the next election that’s what will happen. And then there’ll be no need for you to write as everything on the right will be irrelevant.
A Reform government is actually worse than losing. One thing Rupert Lowe was entirely correct about is that there is nobody in the party giving any serious thought as to what to do with power. A Reform government would be like releasing a raccoon into Heathrow air traffic control. At most it would last eighteen months and be a repeat of the Johnson shitshow - and would then lose to a hard left coalition, from which there is no recovery.
Your confidence level in Reform is amazing 🙂. RL isn't going to do anything except let Labour/a Labour coalition in….then we'll all be truly fkd, if we're not already, before then
I’m sure Reform would fail to deliver all they say they will should they win the next election. Everyone does. However I’d settle for 50% as for 25 years we’ve had nothing good delivered and lots of bad and pointless stuff. I agree that if people intend voting for Lowe and Restore they may as well cut out the middleman and go straight to Labour.
Didn’t you watch Farage, Tice and Goodwin talking about the first 100 days in power yesterday? Plenty of promises on immigration, tax, energy costs including net zero and benefits. Much more too. Looked more serious than anything I’ve heard from the Tories or the left wing loonies.
PR represents the people. An article against PR would be a good idea if it presents alternatives to democracy. A massive parliamentary majority based on 20% of those who can vote makes a mockery of democracy.
Disagree. PR leads to coalitions and gives a disproportionate amount of power to minor parties who make up the majority like the Liberal and Green loonies. A party with as little as say 5% of the vote could be power broker and force a dangerous agenda through which could be totally against the majority wishes.
I think we’d all agree we’ve had crap government of the UK (the world really) for at least 25 years. I believe that’s due to the low standard of intelligence of politicians and their inexperience of the real world rather than the voting system. We have a different system to the EU countries, the USA and others but a similar one to Canada for example. Every country is struggling so it can’t be as easy as changing the system. All PR will do is rig elections to favour socialism in my view. We need to change the people not the system.
I agree. The SDP is also a bit too lefty for me. But I’ve still voted for them, (in the London mayoral) because it made a real change to be able to vote for a candidate, Amy Gallagher, who I felt was a person of character and integrity.
William Clouston will be missed. But best of luck to them.
I do hope they do well and praise from Pete North is worth having. It is a lonely job being a serious political party that never gets anywhere. Maybe it has role in just being there, setting the bar and keeping a flame alive. Like opera or ballet, it doesn’t have mass appeal but we should appreciate the skill that other singers and dancers should emulate. Which won’t happen. Maybe though someone will dare to do something different. An MP jumps ship, a celebrity (bigger than Rod Liddle) signs up or a rich donor takes a punt and suddenly, the game changes.
And then I woke up.
I love reading your work Pete but you’re an idealist, a deep thinker sure but an idealist. Ideas are great and you’re right that we need right wing think tanks to inform serious right wing parties with a chance of power and putting those ideas into practice. You may mock Reform as a slop party and maybe they will fail if they should form a government which I think is highly unlikely but it wouldn’t be as disastrous as this Labour shitshow.
PS. What about an article on Burnham’s crusade to introduce PR and ensure we have a left wing coalition forever because be in no doubt if the right don’t win the next election that’s what will happen. And then there’ll be no need for you to write as everything on the right will be irrelevant.
A Reform government is actually worse than losing. One thing Rupert Lowe was entirely correct about is that there is nobody in the party giving any serious thought as to what to do with power. A Reform government would be like releasing a raccoon into Heathrow air traffic control. At most it would last eighteen months and be a repeat of the Johnson shitshow - and would then lose to a hard left coalition, from which there is no recovery.
Your confidence level in Reform is amazing 🙂. RL isn't going to do anything except let Labour/a Labour coalition in….then we'll all be truly fkd, if we're not already, before then
I’m sure Reform would fail to deliver all they say they will should they win the next election. Everyone does. However I’d settle for 50% as for 25 years we’ve had nothing good delivered and lots of bad and pointless stuff. I agree that if people intend voting for Lowe and Restore they may as well cut out the middleman and go straight to Labour.
Didn’t you watch Farage, Tice and Goodwin talking about the first 100 days in power yesterday? Plenty of promises on immigration, tax, energy costs including net zero and benefits. Much more too. Looked more serious than anything I’ve heard from the Tories or the left wing loonies.
Sloganeering is not policy making.
Agreed Pete. And we know one thing, the left really know how to work the levers of power.
Reform's wishlist remains as likely as the one I had for the Tooth Fairy aged 7.
You were the reason I joined Substack but feel free to ban me from yours.
How is “We promise to reduce your utilities bills by £250pa” a slogan? Ridiculous.
PR represents the people. An article against PR would be a good idea if it presents alternatives to democracy. A massive parliamentary majority based on 20% of those who can vote makes a mockery of democracy.
Disagree. PR leads to coalitions and gives a disproportionate amount of power to minor parties who make up the majority like the Liberal and Green loonies. A party with as little as say 5% of the vote could be power broker and force a dangerous agenda through which could be totally against the majority wishes.
What is your alternative to PR?
I think we’d all agree we’ve had crap government of the UK (the world really) for at least 25 years. I believe that’s due to the low standard of intelligence of politicians and their inexperience of the real world rather than the voting system. We have a different system to the EU countries, the USA and others but a similar one to Canada for example. Every country is struggling so it can’t be as easy as changing the system. All PR will do is rig elections to favour socialism in my view. We need to change the people not the system.
I agree. The SDP is also a bit too lefty for me. But I’ve still voted for them, (in the London mayoral) because it made a real change to be able to vote for a candidate, Amy Gallagher, who I felt was a person of character and integrity.
William Clouston will be missed. But best of luck to them.
Clouston was never a politician. He was a thinker, a reasonable man - and honest. All of which disqualified him for a career in UK politics
Social Democrat = Liberal Democrat = Lefties.
The last leader of the SDP (Clouston) is on the advisory board on immigration with Restore.
Odd how he was a serious political figure for the SDP being selected to work with Restore he’s now not so serious.
Ho hum.